October 2026 at a glance
Measure | McAlester | Pittsburg County |
|---|---|---|
Active listings | 103 | 250 |
New listings | 26 | 47 |
Closed sales | 21 | 30 |
Median list price | $235,000 | $274,750 |
Median sold price | $165,000 | $167,450 |
Average days on market | 69 | 77 |
Months of inventory | 4.9 | 8.3 |
Based on information from MLS Technology, Inc. for the period October 1 through October 31, 2026. How we source these numbers
Type your address into a real estate website and a number comes back in about two seconds. That's usually where people start, and more often than not it's where they stop.
I'll give that number more credit than you'd expect from somebody in my line of work. If your house is a standard three bedroom in town and a few similar ones sold down the street this year, it's probably close. The problem is how rarely that describes a house around here.
So what is a house actually worth?
There's a formal definition, and the appraiser your lender sends works from it. Market value is the "most probable price" a home should bring on the open market, with buyer and seller both informed and neither one under pressure. Notice the word probable. Even the official definition admits it's an estimate.
And notice where the value actually sits. It isn't in your walls. It's in who happened to be shopping that month, what else they could have bought, and whether anybody was in a hurry.
That's why I give sellers a range instead of a number, and the range isn't me hedging. It comes straight out of the comps. When they cluster within a few thousand dollars of each other, the range is tight. When they're scattered, it isn't, and that scatter tells you how sure the market is about houses like yours.
What goes into the number
Before I pull a single comp, I walk the property, because you can't choose comparable sales until you've seen what you're comparing.
Then I look at what closed, not what's listed. Anybody can ask any price they want, so asking prices only tell you what sellers were hoping for. Closed sales tell you what somebody actually paid.
Buyers price the big systems first. Roof age, heat and air, plumbing, electrical, foundation. Nobody is going to pay you extra for a roof that works, but everybody deducts for one that doesn't, usually more than the repair would have run you. So those things protect your value without adding to it, which is not what most sellers expect to hear.
Nobody is going to pay you extra for a roof that works, but everybody deducts for one that doesn't.
What adds is what shows. Flooring, counters, paint. That's what changes how a buyer feels in the first room. It's also what changes how the photographs look, and the photographs decide whether anybody comes to see the house at all.
And that's where sellers misjudge their own homes most often. You quit noticing what you've lived with for fifteen years, while a buyer catches all of it in about ninety seconds.
Then the appraiser gets a vote
If there's a loan involved, one more person weighs in before any of this is settled.
The lender sends an appraiser, and the loan is based on the lower of two numbers: the price you agreed to or the appraised value. A buyer can agree to pay anything. A lender will only lend against what the appraisal supports, so when the appraisal comes in low, somebody has to make up the difference or the deal changes shape.
Three ways to price it
All of which brings you to the only decision that's really yours. When I sit down with a seller, I lay out three options.
The first is the one I try to talk people out of. We price it where you want it priced, and then it sits. A few months later we end up taking less than we listed it for anyway.
The second is to list at the high end of your range and see how the market reacts. If nothing happens, we drop the price month by month until somebody writes an offer.
The one I recommend is to start in the middle of that range and watch the same way. But if showings and offers don't come in the first two to four weeks, we adjust right then, while the listing is still fresh.
Timing is the real difference. Adjusting early brings more buyers through the door while people are still paying attention. Adjusting late only confirms what everybody had already started to assume.
Which is also why the days on market figure in the box above is worth a look. A house priced right usually lands on the short side of it.
Next month: what happens after your offer is accepted.
Have a question about buying, selling, or the local market? Send it to [email protected] and Jacob may answer it in a future column.
Jacob Beaty is a licensed real estate agent with Keller Williams Realty SEOK in McAlester, and he writes Dirt and Deeds each month. More about Jacob
Market value definition from the Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.1-01. Loan value rule from B2-1.2-01.
