
200 E. Carl Albert Pkwy, McAlester, OK 74501 | 918-423-1414 | Monday through Friday, 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Food: 4 out of 5. Staff and service: 5 out of 5.
Lucy's Two sits in the old Aldridge building downtown, and walking in feels less like entering a restaurant and more like walking into somebody's kitchen at the busiest part of the day. There was a haze of grill smoke in the air when I came through the door. It never bothered my eyes. It just told me the flat top was working.
The place was full. Every table had somebody in it, and I recognized more than a few faces, which is about what you expect at a lunch counter that has been feeding this town for years. The menu lives on chalkboards behind the counter, hand lettered in blue and white, and you order at the register.

I ordered the Reuben. On the board it goes by Randall's Reuben, and it lives under Grilled Paninis, not under Sandwiches. I asked for spicy mustard instead of the Thousand Island. The kitchen did not blink. What came back was cooked to perfection, pressed until the bread cracked when I bit it, the corned beef hot all the way through, and the mustard doing exactly what I hoped it would do against the kraut and the cheese. If you like a Reuben with some bite to it, ask for that swap. They will make it.
For the side I took the black eyed pea salad, which the board calls Texas Caviar. Sides run about three dollars. It is black eyed peas with tomatoes and peppers, cold and fresh, and it was tasty. My only note is that it could stand a little more seasoning. A pinch more salt or a heavier hand with the vinegar would take it from good to memorable. That is a small thing, and it is the reason the food lands at a four instead of a five.
The sweet tea came out warm. Not room temperature warm, but warmer than a glass of sweet tea in Oklahoma in September has any business being. Ask for extra ice and you have solved it.
The service is where Lucy's Two runs away with it. The staff moved fast, kept a full dining room turning, and stayed friendly the whole time. Nobody was rushed and nobody was ignored. That is hard to pull off during a lunch rush, and they made it look easy. Five out of five, no hesitation.
A few practical notes before you go. Lunch is served in house and dinner is available to go. The website at lucystwo.com is still under construction, so the Facebook page is the best place to check daily soups and desserts. The sign by the register says call-in orders are cash only, so plan for that if you are phoning ahead. And save room, because the dessert board lists bread pudding, carrot cake, German chocolate cake, New York cheesecake, and strawberry pie.
Go hungry. Ask for the mustard. Bring cash if you call it in.
